China’s mass surveillance operation has a new target: distracted high school students.
In March, Hangzhou Number 11 High School in east China installed a “smart classroom behavior management system” (or “smart eye”) in one of its classrooms. The smart eye uses facial recognition technology to monitor students, and by this summer, administrators plan to install the Big Brother-esque system in every classroom.
Here’s how it works. Every 30 seconds, three cameras installed in the front of the room scan each student’s face to determine their expression: surprised, sad, antipathy, angry, happy, afraid, or neutral.
The cameras also record each student’s actions throughout the class, noting whether they are reading, listening, writing, standing up, raising hands, or leaning on the desk.
Smart eye then notifies the teacher in real-time if it notices that a student appears distracted. The teacher can also view a report at the end of the class that provides an average of each student’s expressions.
The school’s headmaster, Ni Ziyuan, told Chinese-government-run news site Hangzhou that the goal behind using the smart eye is to help teachers improve based on student reactions. Which sounds positive. But that’s not the whole story. Students are also graded on how well they’re paying attention.
“[T]hose [students] who focus on lectures will be marked with an A, while students who let their minds wander will be marked with a B,” Ni told Hangzhou.
The Chinese education system is already notoriously demanding of students, and as one student told Hangzhou, the smart eye system adds to the pressure: “I don’t dare be distracted since the cameras were installed in the classrooms. It’s like a pair of mystery eyes are constantly watching me.”
“They are not studying machines. Any human being will have moments when their mind wanders,” one commenter wrote on Sina Weibo, China’s version of Twitter, in reference to the smart eye system.
Using surveillance to catch jaywalkers or criminals is one thing. But to essentially try to turn students into learning machines? That might only end up hurting China’s citizens in the long run.